GutCheck Community
the men's board for guts, dad bods and getting dressed · est. 2014

The beer wasn't the problem. I checked.

Started by MikeSully47, 07-29-2026 · 26 replies · 14,882 views
MS
MikeSully47
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2021
Posts: 184
Ohio
07-29-2026, 09:14 AM #1

Long post, sorry. Posting it because I wish someone had posted it for me.

At 47, I eat less than I ever have. The gut has never been bigger.

The beer went first. Two months without a drop. The gut stayed exactly where it was. I barely drink these days anyway. A beer gut, without the beer.

So I figured it was on me. A hundred crunches every other day, until my back hurt and the gut hadn't changed. Three winters on a treadmill at 5:45 in the morning.

The one place I saw a change was my wrist. My watch got loose.

For years my standing joke was that I've got a six pack, it's just covered by the one pack. Then my kid asked me if there was a baby in my belly. I said no, buddy. I retired the joke after that.

The gym made it worse. The place is full of twenty-somethings living their best life, doing my same routine, and their gut was gone within months. Mine stayed.

I was sure I was doing something wrong. My brother-in-law is 54 and his shirt sits flat. The first thing he said sounded like he was telling me to give up.

"You can do everything right and still carry it"

He said: "After 40, the gut is first on and last off. If it comes off at all. You can do everything right and still carry it."

I told him that's a hell of a thing to hear in year six.

It explained the younger guys, though. They're not past 40 yet.

Then he said: "You're not going to shrink it. You can change how it sits, though."

I told him I'm not wearing a girdle

Because that's what "change how it sits" sounded like to me.

Besides, I've seen compression shirts at the gym. They show no mercy on a guy with a gut.

He said that's because those guys wear them as the shirt. This goes under your shirt, like an undershirt. It's got panels in the front and sides. Holds everything together.

I still didn't buy it. A real gut is solid. There's not much to squeeze.

He said: "It doesn't squeeze you thinner. It holds it together, so nothing hangs over your belt and the shirt on top sits flat. Same day. Not some eventually thing."

My own system was shirts a size up, worn untucked. My real size shows the gut the second I lift my arms, and the size up is baggy and looks like shit. There is no size that just fits. That was my way of handling it. Maybe yours is the belt under the belly, or the shirt that stays on at the pool.

I wasn't all the way sold, but I ordered one.

"You been working out?"

The first morning I expected a fight to get into it. It took about ten seconds. Goes on like any tank, shirt over it.

I figured people would be able to tell. Under my polo you couldn't see a thing.

I caught myself in the elevator glass on the way in. I wasn't sucking it in. The shirt sat flat.

A coworker asked if I'd been working out. I didn't correct him.

So is it cheating?

Not correcting him felt like getting away with something. I'd been trying for six years. The fix took about ten seconds. The first day it felt like faking it.

Then I thought about my eyes. They went at 43. I bought glasses, and nobody calls glasses cheating.

And nothing about it is fake. The gut is still there. The tank just holds it together while I work on the rest.

I was never chasing abs anyway. I just wanted to stop sucking it in to look normal.

I spent six years thinking I wasn't trying hard enough. That was never it. I just didn't have the right thing under my shirt.

Odds are you don't either. If even one guy skips year seven of crunches because of this post, it was worth the typing.

EDIT: a few of you asked which one it is. It's the Alpha tank from Mount Alpha: mount-alpha.com/products/alpha-tank-top — $29.90. They do a buy 2 get 1 free thing and there's a 90 day money back guarantee, which is honestly the only reason I risked it.
👍 214 guys liked this QuoteReport
BD
BigTex_Dave
Member
Joined: Jun 2023
Posts: 41
Texas
07-29-2026, 10:02 AM #2

I, like many people in the world, have put on a few pounds over the past 18 months. The majority of it has decided to hunker down around my gut, and I'm tired of it. Following this.

👍 32 QuoteReport
HH
hardgut_hank
Member
Joined: Jan 2020
Posts: 312
07-29-2026, 11:40 AM #3

Gonna be honest with you, a real beer belly is often quite solid. Mine is hard as a rock. There's nothing to squeeze, so I don't see how a shirt does anything.

👍 18 QuoteReport
MS
MikeSully47
Senior Member · OP
Joined: Mar 2021
Posts: 184
Ohio
07-29-2026, 12:15 PM #4

Mine's solid too. That's exactly why I didn't believe it either. It's not squeezing it smaller, nothing under the shirt changes. It holds it so nothing hangs over the belt, and the shirt on top sits flat instead of catching on the shelf. That line under the shirt is the whole difference.

👍 44 QuoteReport
DM
Denver_Mike_58
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 507
Colorado
07-29-2026, 02:51 PM #5

lol I lost 40lbs once and didn't even know it because I still had the round belly. Went from an XL to a M and didn't realize. It's the last place it goes, if it goes at all. Nobody tells you that part when you're 30.

👍 51 QuoteReport
JT
JT_1972
Member
Joined: Feb 2022
Posts: 96
07-29-2026, 04:19 PM #6

Compression shirts show no mercy to anyone with even the slightest belly. Seen enough of them at my gym to know. You sure about this one?

👍 12 QuoteReport
MS
MikeSully47
Senior Member · OP
Joined: Mar 2021
Posts: 184
Ohio
07-29-2026, 05:03 PM #7

That was my objection too. Those guys wear them AS the shirt, that's the mistake. This goes under a normal shirt like an undershirt. The compression part is never visible. What people see is a regular polo sitting flat.

👍 29 QuoteReport
KG
whole_keg_kev
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2018
Posts: 843
07-29-2026, 08:47 PM #8

Why have a six pack when you can have the whole keg 🍺 And mine's a rum and coke belly, I don't even like beer.

👍 67 QuoteReport
QD
QuietDadOf3
Member
Joined: May 2024
Posts: 18
07-30-2026, 07:32 AM #9

My kid asked me the same baby question at the pool this summer. Laughed it off in the moment. Thought about it the whole drive home. This thread hits.

👍 58 QuoteReport
PM
Paul_in_Michigan
Member
Joined: Aug 2021
Posts: 74
07-30-2026, 09:58 AM #10

What's the sizing like? I'm 5'11 but I have to buy XX Tall in everything just so it doesn't ride up. Buying clothes sucks.

👍 9 QuoteReport
MS
MikeSully47
Senior Member · OP
Joined: Mar 2021
Posts: 184
Ohio
07-30-2026, 10:21 AM #11

They size it by body weight, not chest. Goes up to 5XL, site says up to 463 lbs. Size chart is on the product page: mount-alpha.com/products/alpha-tank-top. The ride-up thing hasn't happened to me, it's long enough to stay tucked into the waistband.

👍 21 QuoteReport
NS
NotFatJustSoft
Member
Joined: Apr 2023
Posts: 29
07-31-2026, 06:44 PM #12

I'm not "fat" but I look soft, and this whole thread is me. Especially the sucking it in part. I've been sucking in my gut for 30 years. At my desk, in photos, walking past any window. I just don't want to have to suck it in to look normal.

👍 73 QuoteReport
RW
RickW_undershirt
Member
Joined: Oct 2022
Posts: 133
08-01-2026, 08:12 AM #13

Can confirm, I've worn one of these for about a year. It doesn't mean you look thinner necessarily, it just holds it together. Which honestly is all I wanted. Under a polo nobody can tell there's anything there. Warm in summer though, fair warning.

👍 36 QuoteReport
GB
Gary_B_54
Member
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 210
08-02-2026, 09:30 PM #14

Ordered one. If a shirt can do what six years of 5am treadmill couldn't, I'll take the L on pride. The 90 day return thing sealed it, worst case I send it back.

👍 25 QuoteReport
view 13 more replies
You must be registered to reply. Register